Barstow Man Who Possibly Got Away with 2016 Murder Arrested Again For Murder

Barstow Man Who Possibly Got Away with 2016 Murder Arrested Again For Murder

BARSTOW – Less than a year following an arrest for the murder of a different Barstow man, 44-year-old Scott Brodie is back behind bars for murder authorities said.

Brodie was arrested on June 22, 2016, for the murder of 33-year-old Robert Whitnack who was found shot at Brodie’s home located in the 36200 block of Ramirez Road near Old Highway 58. For reasons that remain unclear, Brodie was released just two days later on June 24, 2016.

On May 13, 2017, deputies from the Barstow Station again responded to his home  regarding information they received about a possible shooting and homicide that reportedly took place on May 10, 2017. On Tuesday, May 16, 2017, Homicide investigator responded to the scene to assume the investigation. Numerous interviews were conducted and the following day a search warrant was served on Brodie’s home.

Brodie was detained for questioning while a K9 Deputy and his K9 partner, “Ellie” who is trained to detect human remains responded to the scene. Ellie eagerly got to work and alerted to a specific location. The area Ellie alerted to was excavated and a male body was found. Brodie was arrested and booked the High Desert Detention Center for murder. He is being held without bail.

On Thursday, May 19, 2017, fingerprints of the deceased man identified him as 33-year-old Archie Stewart of Barstow.

Anyone with information regarding this investigation is urged to contact Detective Brendan Motley or Sergeant Greg Myler, Homicide Detail (909) 387-3589. Callers wishing to remain anonymous are urged to call the We-Tip Hotline at 1-800-78CRIME (27463), or you may leave information on the We-Tip website at

For late-breaking news, follow 24/7 Headline News on our Los Angeles County Facebook group, Riverside County Facebook group, Coachella Valley News groupUS News group, Victor Valley/Inland Empire Facebook group. If you like what we are doing and want regular updates on your facebook stream like our Facebook Fan Page. You may also follow 24/7 Headline News on Twitter and Instagram! 

Staff Writer

This article was written by a staff member of the 24/7 Headline News Organization

Image Sources:

  • Scott-Brodie: Social Media (Facebook)
  • tham

    So bizarre. Released two days after his earlier homicide arrest less than a year ago? Now a buried body in his yard? He’s got a facebook page looking for girlfriends, lol including sappy quotes.

  • Tina Woolridge Trujillo

    My prayers and condolences to Archie
    family, it’s awful this man was killed and had his life taken from him, when he still had his whole life ahead of him yet to live, and he probably might still of been alive today, if his killer would have went to prison in June 2016 for murdering Robert Whittnack, instead of only doing two days and then released to go back out on the streets, even though evidence shown him being guilty of committing the murder of Whittnack. And now due to him not serving a prison term for the 2016 murder, he was allowed to murder another 33year old young man as he done exactly one year ago prior. I hope that Archie family takes action and fights​ against the fact, Archie would not have been killed and still be alive today if they hadn’t ​neglected to serve Justice and sentence Brody to prison for murdering Robert Whittnack, in opposed to letting him go to get away with murder. Rest in peace prayers are with the family and friends and my condolences to you for your tragic loss.. God bless you always.